Dr.Sebastian Champappilly is a well renowned lawyer and Author in India. For Further details clik link
Dr.Sebastian Champappilly
Thursday, August 6, 2009
Champappilly On Ayurveda Law in India
Ayurveda is the most widely recognized Traditional System of Indian Medicine. In the global context, it is known as Complementary and Alternative Medicine (CAM). However, the World Health Organization refers to it as Traditional Medicine (TM). For quite some time in the past, the pseudo modernists, who refused to acknowledge anything that they could not comprehend, tried to build up an attitude of contempt against traditional system of medicine and they could, to a certain extent, keep the system confined to the services of the Adivasi (aboriginals) and the poor in India. However, in recent years, due to the realization of the limitations of modern medicine, there is a renaissance in the field of Traditional Medicine and is rapidly gaining economic importance the world over.
Ayurveda - the ‘Science of Life’.
Ayurveda, which deals with the preventive and curative aspects of health, as already said, comes under the classification of Traditional Medicine (TM) and is in the process of acquiring international recognition. India being its land of origin has overall responsibility to demonstrate before the entire world that it is a science built upon sound principles and practice. As regards principles, there may not be any unanswerable questions. But as regards practice, questions loom large. One and sundry having limited knowledge masquerade themselves as Ayurvedic practitioners and send out a wrong message to the world outside. This situation has to be changed. New strategies are to be evolved. This necessitates formulating a comprehensive National Policy and its implementation requires a legal framework. Unless the legal matrix is in tune with WHO standards, Ayurveda will never get that global recognition which is a sine qua non for tapping international market in the field of Traditional or Alternative Medicines.
In this context it becomes imperative to have an overall view of the existing legal provisions and the safeguards provided there under so that inadequacies can be met by legislative intervention in India. There are several statutes like the Indian Medicine Central Council Act, 1970; The Drugs and Cosmetics Act 1940 and the Rules made thereunder; the Drugs and Magic Remedies (Objectionable Advertisement) Act 1954 and the Rules made thereunder; the Medicinal & Toilet Preparations Act and Rules and the various pieces of State enactments directly affecting the Ayurvedic practice, preparations and education. State enactments like the Madras Medical Registration Act, 1914, the Madras Medical Degrees Act, 1916, the Travancore-Cochin Medical Practitioners Act, 1955 and the Kerala Ayurveda Health Centres (Issue of Licence and Control) Act, 2007 etc are relevant.
The Constitutional obligation of the State. In fact both the Central and the State Governments have a constitutional obligation to protect public health of the citizens and regulate the practice of medicine under Article 47 read with Entries 6 and 26 of State List and Concurrent List respectively of the 7th Schedule to the Constitution of India. Practice of medicine of by unqualified persons pose a serious threat to the health and general well being of the people. It is of utmost importance to the interest of the general public and any connivance at this illegal practice is against the declared object of the enactment of the Indian Medicine Central Council Act 1970 and the Travancore- Cochin Medical Practitioners Act, 1953.
The Kerala scenario. As regards the Travancore-Cochin areas of the State of Kerala, there existed and still exist the Travancore-Cochin Medical Practitioners Act, 1953.This law is in force from 14th October 1953. Medical practitioners belonging to all systems of medicines can get their names registered under this Act and registration is mandatory for any person to practice any system of medicine including Ayurveda. In the Malabar area of the State of Kerala, the Madras Medical Registration Act of 1914 is the law in force. Under section 13 of the said Act, registration of the Allopathic or any other system of Medicine has been permitted. This Act still remains a valid law in Malabar area of the State of Kerala by virtue of Article 372 read with Article 13 (3) (b) of the Constitution of India. This was the position at the commencement of the Constitution of India. This position has not been changed even when Travancore-Cochin became a Part-B State within the Union of India in 1950. With the enactment of the State Reorganisation Act, 1956, the State of Kerala was formed incorporating a part of the Malabar Province of British India. Under Section 119, of the State Reorganization Act, it was provided that existing laws in the respective territories would continue to be in force until altered, amended, modified or repealed by the Legislature of the State. The Madras Medical Registration Act, 1914 has not been repealed or modified by the Legislature of the State of Kerala and hence by the provisions of Constitution and under section 119 of the State Reorganisation Act, the Madras Medical Registration Act, 1914 is still a "law in force" in the Malabar area of the State of Kerala.
In the State of Madras the Indian Medical Degrees Act, 1916 passed by the Indian Legislative Council was in force. This Act was amended by the Indian Medical Degrees (Madras Amendment) Act 1940 and it received the accent of the Governor General on 11th January 1941. It was published in the Fort St. George Gazette on 20th January 1941. By the Indian Medical Degrees (Madras Amendment) Act 1940, the Indian Systems of Medicine was also brought within the purview of the Act.
After Section 6 of the Indian Medical Degrees Act 1916 a new section was added by the Madras Amendment Act of 1940 as Section 6-A. It provided that no person can practise any system of medicine unless he holds a degree, diploma, license or certificate recognized by any law for the time being in force in India or any part thereof. Thereafter, the Central Board of Indigenous Medicine was constituted to grant Medical Registration Certificates to persons holding recognized qualification in the Indian Systems of Medicine and thereafter no person in the Madras Province, including Malabar, could assume title as Doctor and practise any system of medicine without acquiring prescribed qualification and registration. In the State of Madras there was the Central Board of Indigenous Medicine to grant Medical Registration Certificate. Therefore, it can not be contented that there was no State Register in the State of Madras and in Malabar.
Under section 25 of the Indian Medicine Central Council Act, there is a provision for direct registration with the Central Council. Even if there was no State Register, a person cannot practice after the commencement of the IMCC Act, 1970 without a registration either under the Central Act or under the State Act. A person failing to show possession of any of the recognized qualifications entitling him to practice Ayurvedic Medicines, is not entitled to continue practice in that system of medicine. (See the decision reported in ILR (1987) P&H 69 at 80 and AIR 1993 AII 283: 1993 AII LJ II42 (1144) (DB)].
The High Court of Kerala had dismissed several Writ Petitions filed by Parampariya Vaidhayans( traditional practitioners) and their organizations claiming exemption from the requirement of recognized qualification and registration for practicing the Indian System of Medicine including Ayurveda vide the judgment reported as Vanchiyoor Madhom Dhanwanthari Sannidhanam Vs. State of Kerala 2003 (1) KLT 520. The Division Bench has held:- “The Travancore-Cochin Medical Practitioners Act, 1953 was promulgated to regulate the qualifications and to provide for the registration of practitioners of modern medicine. It took within its ambit the homoeopathic and the indigenous system of medicine. Section 23 of the Act inter alia provides that “every holder of a recognized qualification” shall be eligible for registration. The qualifications have been delineated in the Schedule to the statute. So far as Ayurveda and Siddha systems of medicine are concerned, the qualifications are mentioned in Part C. the provisions and procedure for registration have been given. Section 30 requires the Registrar of the Council to publish in the Gazette the list of the names and qualifications of all practitioners registered under the Act. Section 38, to which reference has been made by counsel for the parties, provides as under: “Persons not registered under this Act, etc., not practice.- No person other than (i) a registered practitioner or (ii) a practitioner whose name is entered in the list of practitioners published under Section 30 or (iii) a practitioner whose name is entered in the list mentioned in Section 25 shall practice or hold himself out, whether directly or by implication, as practicing modern medicine, homoeopathic medicine or ayurvedic medicine, siddha medicine or unani tibbi and no person who is not a registered practitioner of any such medicine shall practice any other medicine unless he is also a registered practitioner of that medicine: Provided that the Government may, by notification in the Gazette, direct that this section shall not apply to any person or class of persons or to any specified area in the State where none of the three classes of practitioners mentioned above carries on medical practice: Provided further that this section shall not apply to a practitioner eligible for registration under this Act, who, after having filed the application for registration, is awaiting the decision of the appropriate council or of the Government in case of appeal: Provided also that this section shall not apply to a practitioner eligible for registration under this Act until the period prescribed for application under Section 23 expires.”…………..The 1953 Act was enacted to ensure that only competent and qualified persons practice medicine. Those who were not qualified were ineligible and as such were liable to be punished under section 39. Still further similar provisions were made in the Madras Medical Registration Act, 1914 for the erstwhile Malabar area in the State of Kerala. On a cumulative consideration of the provisions of the two statutes it is clear that persons who have not been registered as medical practitioners are not entitled to administer any medicine. The obvious object of the statutes is to check quackery”. [ See paragraphs 9 & 11 of the judgment].
Following this judgment, the Kerala Ayurveda Health Centres (Issue of Licence and Control) Act, 2007 was enacted by the Kerala Legislature to provide for the issue of licence to Ayurveda Health Centres in the State and to control their function. Now, therefore, a person who is not qualified and registered under the provisions of the Travancore-Cochin Medical Practitioners Act or the Indian Medicine Central Council Act or the Madras Medical Registration Act, cannot practice any system of Medicine in the State of Kerala.
However, the Parampariya Vaidhyans again exerted tremendous pressure on the State Government and therefore the State Government has issued a Government Order (G.O. (Rt. No. 3708/2008/H&FWD dated 10-11-2008) proposing to grant exemption under Section 17(3(c)) to persons who had been practicing Indian System of Medicine for at least 5 years as on the date of commencement of the Indian Medicines Central Council Act 1970 i.e., 1-10-1976. It can be found that under section 13 of Madras Medical Registration Act 1914, registration of the Allopathic or any other system of Medicinewas permitted. This Act still remain a valid law in Malabar area of the State of Kerala by virtue of article 372 read with article 13 (3) (b) of the Constitution of India and section 119 of the State Reorganisation Act, 1956. The existence of the Travancore-Cochin Medical Practitioners Act in the Travancore and Cochin areas of the State of Kerala and Madras Medical Registration Act, in Malabar to regulate the qualifications and to provide for the registration practitioners of Indian System of Medicine prior to 1-10-1976 and maintenance of a State register even before the commencement of the Indian Medicine Central Council Act, 1970, no person in the State of Kerala is entitled either to practice Indian System of Medicine without registration or to get relief under Section 17 (3) (c) of the Central Act. The attempt on the part of the State Government to grant further exemption by issuing an executive order byway of a notification is illegal and ultra vires of the State and Central laws and hence unsustainable in law.
Inadequate penal provisions for punishment. It is evident that under the existing law, the practice of Ayurveda has not been duly regulated by proper enforcement of even the existing legal provisions. The punishment for violation of the provisions of the Act is not a cognizable offence as is evident from section 39 of the TCMP Act, section 8 of the Kerala Ayurveda Health Centres (Issue of Licence and Control) Act, 2007 and section 17 (4) of the IMCC Act and the violators of the law go scot-free with the payment of a minor penalty.
The lack of legal recognition and status. There is, it is alleged, step motherly treatment to the Ayurvedic practitioners. Ayurvedic Practitioners are not given due recognition under the Travancore- Cochin Public Health Act, 1955 and thereby they are not entitled to exercise powers in relation to the maintenance of public health. Further, even in the Mental Health Act, the role of Ayurveda is not recognized. Standardization of the practice of Ayurveda by revamping the legal provisions is essential for the development and attainment of global recognition for Ayurveda.
Globalization and its consequences for Ayurveda
The Constitutional obligation of the State. In fact both the Central and the State Governments have a constitutional obligation to protect public health of the citizens and regulate the practice of medicine under Article 47 read with Entries 6 and 26 of State List and Concurrent List respectively of the 7th Schedule to the Constitution of India. Practice of medicine of by unqualified persons pose a serious threat to the health and general well being of the people. It is of utmost importance to the interest of the general public and any connivance at this illegal practice is against the declared object of the enactment of the Indian Medicine Central Council Act 1970 and the Travancore- Cochin Medical Practitioners Act, 1953.
The Kerala scenario. As regards the Travancore-Cochin areas of the State of Kerala, there existed and still exist the Travancore-Cochin Medical Practitioners Act, 1953.This law is in force from 14th October 1953. Medical practitioners belonging to all systems of medicines can get their names registered under this Act and registration is mandatory for any person to practice any system of medicine including Ayurveda. In the Malabar area of the State of Kerala, the Madras Medical Registration Act of 1914 is the law in force. Under section 13 of the said Act, registration of the Allopathic or any other system of Medicine has been permitted. This Act still remains a valid law in Malabar area of the State of Kerala by virtue of Article 372 read with Article 13 (3) (b) of the Constitution of India. This was the position at the commencement of the Constitution of India. This position has not been changed even when Travancore-Cochin became a Part-B State within the Union of India in 1950. With the enactment of the State Reorganisation Act, 1956, the State of Kerala was formed incorporating a part of the Malabar Province of British India. Under Section 119, of the State Reorganization Act, it was provided that existing laws in the respective territories would continue to be in force until altered, amended, modified or repealed by the Legislature of the State. The Madras Medical Registration Act, 1914 has not been repealed or modified by the Legislature of the State of Kerala and hence by the provisions of Constitution and under section 119 of the State Reorganisation Act, the Madras Medical Registration Act, 1914 is still a "law in force" in the Malabar area of the State of Kerala.
In the State of Madras the Indian Medical Degrees Act, 1916 passed by the Indian Legislative Council was in force. This Act was amended by the Indian Medical Degrees (Madras Amendment) Act 1940 and it received the accent of the Governor General on 11th January 1941. It was published in the Fort St. George Gazette on 20th January 1941. By the Indian Medical Degrees (Madras Amendment) Act 1940, the Indian Systems of Medicine was also brought within the purview of the Act.
After Section 6 of the Indian Medical Degrees Act 1916 a new section was added by the Madras Amendment Act of 1940 as Section 6-A. It provided that no person can practise any system of medicine unless he holds a degree, diploma, license or certificate recognized by any law for the time being in force in India or any part thereof. Thereafter, the Central Board of Indigenous Medicine was constituted to grant Medical Registration Certificates to persons holding recognized qualification in the Indian Systems of Medicine and thereafter no person in the Madras Province, including Malabar, could assume title as Doctor and practise any system of medicine without acquiring prescribed qualification and registration. In the State of Madras there was the Central Board of Indigenous Medicine to grant Medical Registration Certificate. Therefore, it can not be contented that there was no State Register in the State of Madras and in Malabar.
Under section 25 of the Indian Medicine Central Council Act, there is a provision for direct registration with the Central Council. Even if there was no State Register, a person cannot practice after the commencement of the IMCC Act, 1970 without a registration either under the Central Act or under the State Act. A person failing to show possession of any of the recognized qualifications entitling him to practice Ayurvedic Medicines, is not entitled to continue practice in that system of medicine. (See the decision reported in ILR (1987) P&H 69 at 80 and AIR 1993 AII 283: 1993 AII LJ II42 (1144) (DB)].
The High Court of Kerala had dismissed several Writ Petitions filed by Parampariya Vaidhayans( traditional practitioners) and their organizations claiming exemption from the requirement of recognized qualification and registration for practicing the Indian System of Medicine including Ayurveda vide the judgment reported as Vanchiyoor Madhom Dhanwanthari Sannidhanam Vs. State of Kerala 2003 (1) KLT 520. The Division Bench has held:- “The Travancore-Cochin Medical Practitioners Act, 1953 was promulgated to regulate the qualifications and to provide for the registration of practitioners of modern medicine. It took within its ambit the homoeopathic and the indigenous system of medicine. Section 23 of the Act inter alia provides that “every holder of a recognized qualification” shall be eligible for registration. The qualifications have been delineated in the Schedule to the statute. So far as Ayurveda and Siddha systems of medicine are concerned, the qualifications are mentioned in Part C. the provisions and procedure for registration have been given. Section 30 requires the Registrar of the Council to publish in the Gazette the list of the names and qualifications of all practitioners registered under the Act. Section 38, to which reference has been made by counsel for the parties, provides as under: “Persons not registered under this Act, etc., not practice.- No person other than (i) a registered practitioner or (ii) a practitioner whose name is entered in the list of practitioners published under Section 30 or (iii) a practitioner whose name is entered in the list mentioned in Section 25 shall practice or hold himself out, whether directly or by implication, as practicing modern medicine, homoeopathic medicine or ayurvedic medicine, siddha medicine or unani tibbi and no person who is not a registered practitioner of any such medicine shall practice any other medicine unless he is also a registered practitioner of that medicine: Provided that the Government may, by notification in the Gazette, direct that this section shall not apply to any person or class of persons or to any specified area in the State where none of the three classes of practitioners mentioned above carries on medical practice: Provided further that this section shall not apply to a practitioner eligible for registration under this Act, who, after having filed the application for registration, is awaiting the decision of the appropriate council or of the Government in case of appeal: Provided also that this section shall not apply to a practitioner eligible for registration under this Act until the period prescribed for application under Section 23 expires.”…………..The 1953 Act was enacted to ensure that only competent and qualified persons practice medicine. Those who were not qualified were ineligible and as such were liable to be punished under section 39. Still further similar provisions were made in the Madras Medical Registration Act, 1914 for the erstwhile Malabar area in the State of Kerala. On a cumulative consideration of the provisions of the two statutes it is clear that persons who have not been registered as medical practitioners are not entitled to administer any medicine. The obvious object of the statutes is to check quackery”. [ See paragraphs 9 & 11 of the judgment].
Following this judgment, the Kerala Ayurveda Health Centres (Issue of Licence and Control) Act, 2007 was enacted by the Kerala Legislature to provide for the issue of licence to Ayurveda Health Centres in the State and to control their function. Now, therefore, a person who is not qualified and registered under the provisions of the Travancore-Cochin Medical Practitioners Act or the Indian Medicine Central Council Act or the Madras Medical Registration Act, cannot practice any system of Medicine in the State of Kerala.
However, the Parampariya Vaidhyans again exerted tremendous pressure on the State Government and therefore the State Government has issued a Government Order (G.O. (Rt. No. 3708/2008/H&FWD dated 10-11-2008) proposing to grant exemption under Section 17(3(c)) to persons who had been practicing Indian System of Medicine for at least 5 years as on the date of commencement of the Indian Medicines Central Council Act 1970 i.e., 1-10-1976. It can be found that under section 13 of Madras Medical Registration Act 1914, registration of the Allopathic or any other system of Medicinewas permitted. This Act still remain a valid law in Malabar area of the State of Kerala by virtue of article 372 read with article 13 (3) (b) of the Constitution of India and section 119 of the State Reorganisation Act, 1956. The existence of the Travancore-Cochin Medical Practitioners Act in the Travancore and Cochin areas of the State of Kerala and Madras Medical Registration Act, in Malabar to regulate the qualifications and to provide for the registration practitioners of Indian System of Medicine prior to 1-10-1976 and maintenance of a State register even before the commencement of the Indian Medicine Central Council Act, 1970, no person in the State of Kerala is entitled either to practice Indian System of Medicine without registration or to get relief under Section 17 (3) (c) of the Central Act. The attempt on the part of the State Government to grant further exemption by issuing an executive order byway of a notification is illegal and ultra vires of the State and Central laws and hence unsustainable in law.
Inadequate penal provisions for punishment. It is evident that under the existing law, the practice of Ayurveda has not been duly regulated by proper enforcement of even the existing legal provisions. The punishment for violation of the provisions of the Act is not a cognizable offence as is evident from section 39 of the TCMP Act, section 8 of the Kerala Ayurveda Health Centres (Issue of Licence and Control) Act, 2007 and section 17 (4) of the IMCC Act and the violators of the law go scot-free with the payment of a minor penalty.
The lack of legal recognition and status. There is, it is alleged, step motherly treatment to the Ayurvedic practitioners. Ayurvedic Practitioners are not given due recognition under the Travancore- Cochin Public Health Act, 1955 and thereby they are not entitled to exercise powers in relation to the maintenance of public health. Further, even in the Mental Health Act, the role of Ayurveda is not recognized. Standardization of the practice of Ayurveda by revamping the legal provisions is essential for the development and attainment of global recognition for Ayurveda.
Globalization and its consequences for Ayurveda
Globalization has brought opportunities for exploitation of the global market for traditional medicine and its practitioners. Traditional Medicines have an annual share of millions of dollars in the world market. Ayurveda can definitely claim a good share of it, if it meets international standards. This mandates legislation in conformity with WHO regulations. WHO Reports on the Promotion and Development of Traditional Medicine[2], Supplementary Guidelines for the Manufacture of Herbal Medicinal Products,[3] Traditional and Modern Medicine Harmonizing the Two Approaches[4], Guidelines for the Appropriate use of Herbal Medicines[5] and the Basic Tests for Drugs as contemplated in the Pharmaceutical Substances, Medicinal Plant Materials and Dosage Forms are some of the norms to be followed.[6] Again, in the matter of good manufacturing practices, Supplementary Guidelines for the Manufacture of Herbal Medicinal Products[7] and the Guidelines for the Assessment of Herbal Medicines[8] are also prescribed by the WHO.
Response of other nations to globalization
Response of other nations to globalization
Globalization has helped nations to claim intellectual property rights for traditional knowledge including traditional medicine. The TRIPS Agreement reflects this. The traditional Chinese medicine has already secured a good share of the world market. They could achieve this through internal regulations and Constitutional protections. The Chinese Constitution of 1949 has recognized and defined the role of traditional Chinese medicine in the health care system. A national policy was evolved with sound legal support. Vietnam adopted a national policy on traditional medicine in 1955. The Republic of Korea adopted a national policy on traditional medicine in 1969. Even small countries like Singapore have already made substantial progress in this matter. They have made an attempt for regulation of the practice of traditional Chinese medicine by the enactment of a Traditional Chinese Medicine Practitioners Act, 2000 (Act No. 34 of 2000), which is broadly in conformity with the WHO guidelines. This has helped those countries to attain international recognition for their traditional medicine and thereby get a share from the international market. Their legal support to the traditional medicine has helped them to get them classified by WHO in the group of countries as having integrative approach to traditional medicine, whereas India, with so much of knowledge and practice and acceptance of traditional medicine among its people stands clubbed with countries having only an inclusive approach to traditional medicine.[9] As far as India is concerned, it could bring out a Draft National Policy on Indian System of Medicine only by the year 2001 and it still remains in an embryonic stage. As public health is a subject coming in the Concurrent List[10] in the Constitution of India, both the Central and State Governments are entitled to bring in legislation in this area. Kerala being a State having wide recognition for Ayurveda, can definitely take the lead in these matters. As such, it would only be appropriate for the State of Kerala to bring in a State Policy and a State law, which can act as a role model for rest of India to follow. It is high time that the draft policy of the Government of India is transformed into action by appropriate comprehensive legislation.
The existing law being thoroughly inadequate and perhaps counter productive, there is need for a comprehensive legislation for regulation, registration and standardization including quality control in conformity with International Trade Rules. Apart from this, legislation is required for protection from bio-piracy and protection of Intellectual Property Rights. Further, control and regulation of drugs and cosmetics manufacturing, framing of guidelines for internal patenting of proprietary Ayurveda medicines and Product Information and Regulation are essential. The enactment of a comprehensive Health Professions Act or at least an Indian Medicine Practitioners Act is the need of the hour. Consumer Protection in its various facets, insurance coverage for Ayurvedic treatment and finally the integration of Indian System of Medicine with the National Health Care System are mandated. Any attempt for legislation should address these aspects.
Integrated Approach
The existing law being thoroughly inadequate and perhaps counter productive, there is need for a comprehensive legislation for regulation, registration and standardization including quality control in conformity with International Trade Rules. Apart from this, legislation is required for protection from bio-piracy and protection of Intellectual Property Rights. Further, control and regulation of drugs and cosmetics manufacturing, framing of guidelines for internal patenting of proprietary Ayurveda medicines and Product Information and Regulation are essential. The enactment of a comprehensive Health Professions Act or at least an Indian Medicine Practitioners Act is the need of the hour. Consumer Protection in its various facets, insurance coverage for Ayurvedic treatment and finally the integration of Indian System of Medicine with the National Health Care System are mandated. Any attempt for legislation should address these aspects.
Integrated Approach
An all-inclusive integrated approach can be made by enacting a Health Professions Act which in turn should give scope for passing of Regulations by the subordinate legislative body with adequate representation of qualified and experienced hands in the relevant field as may be required for each branch of medicine including modern medicine. However, this approach has the basic and inherent weakness of being overshadowed by Allopathic Practitioners and there may be a step-motherly treatment to the traditional medicine practitioners under this scheme.
Separate and special legislation
Separate and special legislation
For the aforesaid reasons, it is felt that separate and special legislation dealing with Indian System of Medicine would be more beneficial to Ayurveda and it requires an in-depth study involving clinical practitioners and legal experts. As regards defining the contours of the concepts, definitions and prescribing standards of practice, it is the clinical practitioners who can provide the outlines and guidelines. An analysis of the existing Indian law and its inadequacies especially in the context of the regulations and policies prescribed by the WHO, would require inputs from legal experts as otherwise Ayurveda cannot transcend the national boundaries and attain international recognition. The separate legislation should give emphasis and attention in the following areas.
Quality control and standardization
Quality control and standardization
Quality control in the process and products is an area where the law has to intervene. The first and foremost aspect is education and its standard. The system of education must be revamped. Separate Universities, either under the State or Central legislation, should be established for Ayurveda. Research Centers must be brought under the Universities or special Boards.
Further, it is essential to ensure the safety, efficacy and quality of drugs and ensure that the legal and regulatory mechanisms are set up to maintain the quality of drugs and that they perform their role. Indian Systems of Medicine (ISM) can play a role in the health system of a country only if the drugs have been prepared in a manner that inspires confidence and with the Government support for the use of such drugs. Special attention should be paid to the completion of Pharmacopoeias for all drug-based ISM systems, observance of Good Manufacturing Practices, labeling provisions requiring declaration of ingredients, therapeutic claims in the case of P.P medicines to be backed by efficacy trials, inscription of expiry dates, use of only permissible excipients and frequent testing of survey and statutory samples to build public confidence. States should be encouraged and supported to set up State Drug Testing Laboratories and to renovate and modernize pharmacies. The Industries should be encouraged to make use of Quality Certification Scheme to be introduced by a Statutory Body for batch-by-batch testing and a special drive should be made to stop misleading advertisements. The application of the Magic Remedies and Objectionable Advertisement Act should be reviewed in in relation to the ISM sector and an “ISM Product Information and Regulation Act” may be enacted. Quality Control Centers should be set up or recognized on a regional basis to standardize the in-process quality control of ISM products, modernize traditional processes without changing the concepts of ISM[11]. While framing policies and bringing out legislation, it has to be born in mind that the deliberations and formulation of guidelines by WHO on the subject be adhered to for attaining international recognition for Ayurveda.
Massage Parlours and Panchakarma Centres
Further, it is essential to ensure the safety, efficacy and quality of drugs and ensure that the legal and regulatory mechanisms are set up to maintain the quality of drugs and that they perform their role. Indian Systems of Medicine (ISM) can play a role in the health system of a country only if the drugs have been prepared in a manner that inspires confidence and with the Government support for the use of such drugs. Special attention should be paid to the completion of Pharmacopoeias for all drug-based ISM systems, observance of Good Manufacturing Practices, labeling provisions requiring declaration of ingredients, therapeutic claims in the case of P.P medicines to be backed by efficacy trials, inscription of expiry dates, use of only permissible excipients and frequent testing of survey and statutory samples to build public confidence. States should be encouraged and supported to set up State Drug Testing Laboratories and to renovate and modernize pharmacies. The Industries should be encouraged to make use of Quality Certification Scheme to be introduced by a Statutory Body for batch-by-batch testing and a special drive should be made to stop misleading advertisements. The application of the Magic Remedies and Objectionable Advertisement Act should be reviewed in in relation to the ISM sector and an “ISM Product Information and Regulation Act” may be enacted. Quality Control Centers should be set up or recognized on a regional basis to standardize the in-process quality control of ISM products, modernize traditional processes without changing the concepts of ISM[11]. While framing policies and bringing out legislation, it has to be born in mind that the deliberations and formulation of guidelines by WHO on the subject be adhered to for attaining international recognition for Ayurveda.
Massage Parlours and Panchakarma Centres
In this context it may be mentioned that an area of misuse of Ayurveda is the establishment of Massage Parlours and Panchakarma Centres without adhering to any rules or regulations. This would endanger the acceptance of Ayurveda as a scientific system of medicine. As regards the establishment of Massage Parlours, there should be some definite legal frame work. The Kerala Ayurveda Health Centres (Issue of Licence and Control) Act, 2007 is only a feeble and half-hearted attempt and it is only an eye-wash. In fact, the Singapore legislation (“Massage Establishments Act”) would perhaps serve as a useful tool in dealing with the matter.
The Government of India has prescribed specifications and qualifications for the establishment of Panchakarma Centres.[12] This mandates the availability of a qualified Ayurveda Doctor and minimum space and staff requirements in such establishments. Unfortunately, none of these specifications is followed nor are any standards enforced. In fact, standardization is essential for its acceptance in the global village. Intervention of law is highly essential in this area.
Parampariya chikitsa or parampariya vaidhyam and the right for patent. The threat to Ayurveda in attaining global recognition emanate from the quacks who go on practicing Ayurveda in the name of traditional practice or what is known in local parlance as parampariya chikitsa or parampariya vaidhyam. It can be found that the enactment of Traditional Chinese Medicine Practitioners Act does not take into its fold traditional practitioners of Chinese medicine who were otherwise not qualified in the system. In fact, the Act attempts to regulate the practice of Chinese medicine and not legalize traditional practice of Chinese medicine. While attempting legislation in India, precisely this aspect has to be born in mind. In fact, it can not be disputed that traditional knowledge does not exist. In case, any person has specific knowledge of a process or a product, that can be allowed to be patented but that should not give a license for that person to practice Ayurvedic system of medicine without legally recognized qualification.
The enforcement of standards would require enlistment of qualified medical practitioners. Enlistment requires a process of registration. The present enactment – Indian Medicine Central Council Act, 1970- does not make it mandatory to obtain registration by a practitioner in the Central Register. A new law should make a provision for the maintenance of both a State Register and a Central Register as in the case of Allopathic Practitioners, as mandatory.
Intellectual Property Rights and Ayurveda
The Government of India has prescribed specifications and qualifications for the establishment of Panchakarma Centres.[12] This mandates the availability of a qualified Ayurveda Doctor and minimum space and staff requirements in such establishments. Unfortunately, none of these specifications is followed nor are any standards enforced. In fact, standardization is essential for its acceptance in the global village. Intervention of law is highly essential in this area.
Parampariya chikitsa or parampariya vaidhyam and the right for patent. The threat to Ayurveda in attaining global recognition emanate from the quacks who go on practicing Ayurveda in the name of traditional practice or what is known in local parlance as parampariya chikitsa or parampariya vaidhyam. It can be found that the enactment of Traditional Chinese Medicine Practitioners Act does not take into its fold traditional practitioners of Chinese medicine who were otherwise not qualified in the system. In fact, the Act attempts to regulate the practice of Chinese medicine and not legalize traditional practice of Chinese medicine. While attempting legislation in India, precisely this aspect has to be born in mind. In fact, it can not be disputed that traditional knowledge does not exist. In case, any person has specific knowledge of a process or a product, that can be allowed to be patented but that should not give a license for that person to practice Ayurvedic system of medicine without legally recognized qualification.
The enforcement of standards would require enlistment of qualified medical practitioners. Enlistment requires a process of registration. The present enactment – Indian Medicine Central Council Act, 1970- does not make it mandatory to obtain registration by a practitioner in the Central Register. A new law should make a provision for the maintenance of both a State Register and a Central Register as in the case of Allopathic Practitioners, as mandatory.
Intellectual Property Rights and Ayurveda
While attempting legislation, registration and patenting, the issues relating to intellectual property rights are to be dealt with meticulously as otherwise the traditional knowledge would fall into the hands of private proprietary owners and thereby deprive the people of the inexpensive remedy available in Ayurveda. The establishment of a Traditional Knowledge Resource Classification and a Traditional Knowledge Digital Library and a Data Base on the medical knowledge of Ayurveda as contemplated in the Draft National Policy, would go a long way in safeguarding the rights of the people and that of Ayurvedic Practitioners. This might forestall the grant of patents for the medicinal use of plants used in Ayurveda and other Indian medical systems which have been codified and have been in the public domain for centuries. The increased awareness about the value of traditional knowledge and bio-diversity resources and the provisions relating to natural resources under the TRIPS agreement makes it all the more important to declare a policy for this sector. Issues relating to intellectual property regimes are to be addressed by completion of the data base to inventorise the codified knowledge of Ayurveda, so that the grant of patents can be prevented by showing that there is no discovery or invention in the use or applications which have been known for centuries and documented.
Insurance
Insurance
At present, mediclaim policies of Insurance Companies do not give coverage for securing Ayurvedic treatment and Ayurvedic services. For Ayurveda to attain a status equivalent to other systems of medicine, it is highly necessary to offer health insurance coverage for Ayurvedic treatment and Ayurvedic products. Unfortunately, such a proposal has not found a place in the Draft National Policy and this would keep Ayurvedic treatment one step behind other Traditional Medicine/Complimentary and Alternative Medicines (TM/CAM) in the world. Even in the classification by the WHO, unless insurance coverage is provided for Ayurveda practice, India would always be clubbed with countries having only an ‘inclusive approach’ to traditional medicines. Legislative measures are required for insurance coverage for Ayurvedic treatment and products so as to bring it in par with modern medicine.
The ISM Industry
The ISM Industry
The science of Ayurveda can attain its objectives only if it is technologically made viable. Technological viability requires large scale industrial production of Ayurvedic medicines. To achieve this end, the ISM industry should be declared as a priority Industry and as a Green Industry (Generating no toxic, using natural raw materials-Tax benefits HP model (100% tax holiday for 5 years, 30% for another 5 years.). There must be 100% Tax exemption on funds contributed to Medicinal Plants Board by Industry and no Central Sales Tax shall be levied on identified cultivated Medicinal Plants traded as raw material. Tax benefits ought to be given to companies using cultivated herbs. Income tax exemption should be given to ISM Practitioners/Consultants earning Foreign Exchange. Access to bank loans should be facilitated for undertaking completion of measures set out in GMP. Industries should be encouraged to adopt modern dosage form and follow reasonable shelf-life periods for drugs and formulations. The use of Classical and Shastra preparations should be encouraged. Guidelines should be framed for patent and proprietary Ayurveda medicines and manufactures should be encouraged to have efficacy and safety studies conducted before licenses are granted for new PP medicines.[13] These are some of the measures to expedite export of Ayurvedic medicines and services to other countries to secure foreign exchange so vital for the revival and survival of the system. However, the Indian System of Medicine as a whole gets only 2% of the total health budget of the nation, while 98% goes to the western type modern medicine. A corrective policy needs to be initiated so that ISM can fully realize its potential and occupy a much larger share of the health services as otherwise, it would not be possible for Ayurveda to realize its share of the global market.
Now, therefore, consolidation, codification and up-gradation of the law, in tune with global standards on traditional medicines, have become essential for Ayurveda to claim its due share of the national and global markets. Adoption of such a policy will be in tune with the public policy of making medicines available to the poor at affordable prices
* * * *
[1] Dr. Sebastian Champappilly is an Advocate of the High Court of Kerala
[2] Technical Report of WHO No. 622.
[3] Technical report Series No. 863.
[4] Manila, WHO Regional Office for the Western Pacific-2000.
[5] Manila, WHO Regional Publications Western Pacific Series No. 25.
[6] Geneva, World Health Organization, 1998(F/S).
[7] See Annex 8 of WHO Expert Committee on Specifications for Pharmaceutical Preparations. Thirty-fourth Report. Geneva, World Health Organization, 1996 (WHO Technical Report Series, No. 863) (F/S).
[8] Annex 11 of WHO Expert Committee on Specifications for Pharmaceutical Preparations. Thirty-fourth Report. Geneva, World Health Organization 1996 (WHO Technical Report Series No. 863) (F/S). See the Quality Control Methods for Medicinal Plant Materials. Geneva, World Health Organization, 1998. Also see Guidelines for Training Traditional Health Practitioners in Primary Health Care. Geneva, World Health Organization, 1995 (Document reference WHO/SHS/DHS/TM/95.5).
[9] See WHO Traditional Medicine Strategy 2002-2005 at page 10.
[10] See entry 6 of List II - State List in the 7th Schedule to the Constitution of India.
[11] See the Draft National Policy on Indian System of Medicine, 2001. P. 12.
[12] See Order S. No. Z. 20018/4/2000-ISM-Tech. Govt. of India, Ministry of Health and Family Welfare,
Department of ISM &H dated 6-4-2000.
[13] These are matters already incorporated in the National Policy on Ayurveda, 2001.
Now, therefore, consolidation, codification and up-gradation of the law, in tune with global standards on traditional medicines, have become essential for Ayurveda to claim its due share of the national and global markets. Adoption of such a policy will be in tune with the public policy of making medicines available to the poor at affordable prices
* * * *
[1] Dr. Sebastian Champappilly is an Advocate of the High Court of Kerala
[2] Technical Report of WHO No. 622.
[3] Technical report Series No. 863.
[4] Manila, WHO Regional Office for the Western Pacific-2000.
[5] Manila, WHO Regional Publications Western Pacific Series No. 25.
[6] Geneva, World Health Organization, 1998(F/S).
[7] See Annex 8 of WHO Expert Committee on Specifications for Pharmaceutical Preparations. Thirty-fourth Report. Geneva, World Health Organization, 1996 (WHO Technical Report Series, No. 863) (F/S).
[8] Annex 11 of WHO Expert Committee on Specifications for Pharmaceutical Preparations. Thirty-fourth Report. Geneva, World Health Organization 1996 (WHO Technical Report Series No. 863) (F/S). See the Quality Control Methods for Medicinal Plant Materials. Geneva, World Health Organization, 1998. Also see Guidelines for Training Traditional Health Practitioners in Primary Health Care. Geneva, World Health Organization, 1995 (Document reference WHO/SHS/DHS/TM/95.5).
[9] See WHO Traditional Medicine Strategy 2002-2005 at page 10.
[10] See entry 6 of List II - State List in the 7th Schedule to the Constitution of India.
[11] See the Draft National Policy on Indian System of Medicine, 2001. P. 12.
[12] See Order S. No. Z. 20018/4/2000-ISM-Tech. Govt. of India, Ministry of Health and Family Welfare,
Department of ISM &H dated 6-4-2000.
[13] These are matters already incorporated in the National Policy on Ayurveda, 2001.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)